Skip to main content

Attention healthcare professionals holding or eyeing a real estate investment for its rental income through platforms such as Airbnb or VRBO. A recent ruling by the Tax Court of Canada (2024 TCC 37, 1351231 Ontario Inc. v. His Majesty the King) has brought to light important tax considerations that cannot be ignored. This ruling focuses on the “change of use” rules under Canada’s Excise Tax Act (ETA), uncovering potential tax challenges that could impact your investment’s profitability.

This revelation is more than just a footnote in tax law; it’s a crucial piece of information for anyone involved in short-term rentals. With the complexities of tax laws and the implications they hold for your investments, staying informed and prepared is more important than ever.

  1. Navigating GST/HST Obligations: Healthcare professionals investing in real estate to earn rental income via platforms like Airbnb need to understand the adverse impact of “change of use” rules when shifting from long-term to short-term rentals, or vice versa.
  2. Financial Implications of Property Use Change: The deemed transaction of selling and reacquiring the property at market value upon change in use can have significant GST/HST (and income tax) costs, adversely impacting a property’s cashflow and ROI.
  3. Seek Professional Guidance: Due to the complex tax rules for long and short-term rental properties and recent changes to municipal, provincial and federal laws consulting with an experienced healthcare accountant is essential.

A Closer Look at the Court’s Decision

The recent Tax Court of Canada decision (2024 TCC 37, 1351231 Ontario Inc. v. His Majesty the King) shed light on the complexities of the Excise Tax Act (ETA) as it applies to rental properties. This ruling is particularly relevant for owners of property who generate income from short-term rentals via platforms such as Airbnb and VRBO. It clarified how the “change of use” rules operate within the ETA, highlighting the financial implications of these rules when a property’s use is switched from long-term to short-term rentals or vice versa. Essentially, this case serves as a practical example, demonstrating the ETA’s provisions in action and the associated costs when making what may seem like straightforward business decisions. Additionally, it serves as a valuable reminder for prospective investors, illustrating the consequences should a property be purchased, and its original use changed.

Common Real-Life Scenarios and Their ETA Implications

Imagine Dr. S, who transitions her rental property from a long-term rental to a short-term rental advertising it on Airbnb, expecting higher returns. This strategic shift constitutes a “change in use,” under the ETA transforming her investment from a residential to a commercial activity. Similarly, Dr. J, who intermittently rents out his vacation home on Airbnb, faces potential tax consequences if his rental activity is deemed a significant change in use.  Both decisions could have immediate and costly consequences to both.  These scenarios highlight the nuanced tax implications that investors need to be aware of, stressing the importance of understanding when and how GST/HST obligations are triggered.

Understanding “Change in Use” and Its Consequences

The concept of “change in use” under the ETA essentially means that immediately before the change from long-term residential to short-term commercial rental, the property is considered to have been sold and reacquired at its current market value for purposes of the ETA. This deemed transaction can lead to an immediate and substantial GST/HST obligation to be reported and remitted by the property owner.

At the Time of Change

Upon converting a property’s use to short-term rental use, it may become necessary to start charging GST/HST on the rental income, aligning with the government’s view of short-term rentals as commercial activities. This adjustment in tax treatment underscores the need for property owners to re-evaluate their tax strategy considering obligations imposed by the ETA.

When Deciding to Sell

Selling a short-term rental property may also attract GST/HST, given its classification as commercial real estate at the time of sale. This aspect of the ETA underscores the broader tax implications of changing a property’s use, which could significantly impact the financial viability of such investments.

Navigating Tax Responsibilities

The responsibility to charge, collect, and remit GST/HST will be up to the owner of a short-term rental property. This includes managing tax obligations for both the rental income post-change in use and any proceeds from the sale of the property, should it be considered commercial at the point of sale. The recent court ruling serves as a critical reminder for healthcare professionals who hold rental properties to be aware of their tax responsibilities to avoid potential penalties and interest charges from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).

Guidance for Healthcare Professionals

For healthcare professionals caught off-guard by these tax complexities, the consequences of failing to charge and remit GST/HST can be financially burdensome. Penalties, interest, and the potential need to cover GST/HST out of pocket for past transactions highlight the importance of seeking professional advice. While this article offers a foundational understanding it should not be considered tax or legal advice.  Consulting an experienced healthcare accountant can provide clarity, ensure compliance, and optimize tax strategies critical to ensuring your initial investment strategy is realized.

Safeguarding Your Investment

This recent Tax Court of Canada ruling has shed light on the complex tax dynamics at play for healthcare professionals involved in real estate investing. By understanding the tax implications of “change in use” and embracing proactive tax planning, you can navigate these challenges and continue to grow your investment portfolio wisely. Remember, in the realm of real estate investment, being well-informed and prepared is the best defense against unforeseen tax liabilities.

For further guidance or to discuss your specific situation, consider booking a 30-minute complimentary consultation with Jonathan Tucker, CPA, CA, LPA, who can provide the expertise and support needed to navigate the tax landscape confidently.

Jonathan Tucker